Legal News and Appellate Tips

Each week, TVA appellate attorney Tim Kowal reviews several recent decisions out of the appellate courts in California, and elsewhere, and reports about the ones that might help you get an edge in your cases and appeals.

If you would like to receive weekly updates of the articles posted here, click here to sign up for the newsletter.

Tag: Appealability

"Related"​ Appealable Orders May Be Reviewed Even If Appellant Fails to Appeal Them

One reason I like to read unpublished opinions is they are a little bit less guarded in their analyses. Even if the outcomes would not be different had the opinion been published, the courts sometimes offer analyses that seem somewhat unusual, or incomplete, and these can give a glimpse into how the justices and their research attorneys are struggling through the issues in the case.

I got this impression reading San Felipe Farms L.P. v. LLY Ranch (D4d3 Jul. 8, 2021) no. G060126. It involves an appeal that seems clearly moot, and from an order that seems clearly nonappealable. But the court for some reason did not want to dismiss the appeal on either of those grounds – and in so doing suggests a possible loophole in the appealability doctrine that may be larger than typically advertised.

The court also noted the appellant had put its toes right on the line of its duty of candor.

Read More
Is This Probate Order Appealable? Yes, But "It's Messy,"​ Says Appellate Court

When you are trying to determine if an order is appealable, that question is normally pretty cut-and-dried. But not in the probate case of Manvelian v. Manvel (D2d7 Jun. 22, 2021) no. B297334 (nonpub. opn.). The Second District Court of Appeal spent several paragraphs, evaluated the factual record, and threaded its analytical needle through multiple cases, including 100-year-old Supreme Court precedent, to determine that, though it is a "close call," the order denying a motion to vacate an order confirming a settlement was appealable.

You can usually tell whether the order is appealable just by the title or nature of the order. It should not require researching 100 years of precedent to find out if an order is appealable. But that is what it took here.

The Upshot: If you plan to challenge an order or judgment in a motion to vacate in probate court, try to raise issues and evidence that were not available at the time the underlying order or judgment was issued. That will help ensure an order denying your motion is independently appealable.

But if you do not need to raise new issues or evidence, make sure to timely appeal the underlying order or judgment. (In fact, you might timely appeal it regardless. You should consult an appellate attorney in this situation.)

Read More
Iran Is Not a Suitable Judicial Forum as a Matter of Law, CA Appellate Court Holds

The plaintiffs in Aghaian v. Minassian (D2d8 May 24, 2021) no. B296287 are children of Iranians who fled during the Iranian Revolution. Their parents had amassed a large amount of property, and had asked the defendant, a family friend, to recover it for them. Turns out the defendant used the opportunity to enrich himself by some $34 million. The children sued, and the defendant argued Iran was a more suitable forum. Iran? the Court of Appeal asked. That Iran? Iran is not a suitable forum.

But by the time the first appeal was done, the plaintiff had initiated proceedings in Iran. Now can we litigate in Iran, the defendant asked again? Look, the plaintiffs have waived their objections to Iran!

No, the Court of Appeal responded in this second appeal. We have already decided the question. It is law of the case. Our holding is our holding. It cannot be waived.

But: An order denying a motion for inconvenient forum may be reviewed as an interlocutory order following a final judgment. The defendant did not waive his right to appellate review by failing to file a writ petition.

Read More
Charles Manson's Grandson Not Required to Submit to DNA Testing, Court of Appeal Holds

The Second District Court of Appeal has the latest update in the fight over Charles Manson's estate. After Manson died in 2017, the probate court ordered Freeman was the sole surviving adult next of kin, and authorized to determine the disposition of Manson's remains. Manson penpal and "murderabilia" collector Channels disputed Freeman's kinship, and moved for genetic testing under Probate Code section 6453.

But there is no authority to require genetic testing under section 6453. So held (and without much trouble, really) the Second District in Freeman v. Channels (D2d2 Apr. 13, 2021) no. B303594 (not published).

Before reaching the question, however, the court found a jurisdictional defect. The court concluded the order appealed was not an appealable order. But the court exercised its discretion to treat the appeal as a writ petition because the improper genetic test "will involve an invasion of Freeman's privacy that cannot be undone," leaving Freeman with "no adequate remedy at law."

So Freeman will get to handle the disposition of Manson's remains. He is legally (perhaps strictly so) the prevailing party.

Read More
Orders Granting Terminating Sanctions, and Denying Motions to Vacate and Reconsider, Are Not Appealable: Appeal Dismissed

An order granting terminating sanctions may seem like the end of the world. It isn't. The judgment on the order granting terminating sanctions is the end of the world. Then, and only then, may you appeal.

Chung & Assocs. v. Mendoza (D2d1 Feb. 18, 2021) No. B297304 (unpublished)

Read More
Can You Appeal an Order Denying Leave to Amend a Complaint?

Practitioners know that amendments to pleadings are liberally allowed. But every now and then, they are denied. What can you do then?

An order denying leave to amend is not directly appealable. So that's out.

You could try your case on the existing complaint and appeal if you are unsuccessful. But in that case, it would be difficult to establish any error in denying leave was prejudicial – after all, the trier of fact rejected your evidence.

There's always a writ petition. Good luck with that.

The solution: Strategic voluntary dismissal to expedite an appeal.

Read More
Attorney Fee Orders After Appeal Raise Thorny Appealability Issues

This appeal over attorney fees concerns thorny issues of appealability. In Doe v. Westmont Coll. (D2d6 Jan. 25, 2021) No. B303208, the Second District rejected the college's arguments that the fee order […]

Read More
Court Dismisses Two Appeals in One Case: One as Moot, One as Premature

This recent opinion discusses two appeals, both of them dismissed on procedural grounds. The first appeal was dismissed as moot because the appellant failed to obtain a stay of the […]

Read More

Tags

Podcast (117)
Videos (100)
Appealability and Appealable Orders (37)
Legal Writing (29)
Anti-SLAPP (27)
Abuse of Discretion (24)
Mischief (24)
Splits of Authority (23)
Unpublished Opinions (22)
Statements of Decision (21)
Notices of Appeal (20)
Waiver and Forfeiture (20)
Stays on Appeal (20)
California Supreme Court (20)
Judgment Enforcement (18)
Oral Argument (18)
Timely and Untimely Appeals (18)
Arbitration (18)
Attorney Fees (17)
Record on Appeal (17)
Trial Strategy (15)
Dismissals (14)
Sanctions (14)
Briefing (14)
Evidentiary Objections (14)
Writ Petitions (13)
Dissents (13)
Appellate Sanctions (13)
Summary Judgments and Summary Adjudications (13)
Civility (12)
Dismissed Appeals (12)
Preliminary Injunctions (12)
Timeliness (12)
Collateral Orders (12)
Jurisdiction (12)
Exclusion of Evidence (12)
Experts (11)
Family Law (11)
New Trial Motions (11)
Mootness (11)
CCP 998 Offers (11)
Trial Procedure (10)
Federal Courts (10)
Motions for Reconsideration (10)
Posttrial Motions (10)
Admission of Improper Evidence (9)
Implied Findings (9)
Settlements (8)
Standards of Review (8)
Appealability (8)
Disqualification (7)
Default Judgments (7)
Stipulated Judgments (7)
Appellate Bonds (7)
Ninth Circuit (7)
Pretrial Procedure (7)
Probate Appeals (7)
Respondent Arguments (7)
Mediation (6)
Petitions for Review (6)
Appellate Briefing (6)
Depublished Opinions (6)
Ethical Duty of Candor (6)
Substantial Evidence (6)
Appellate Practice (6)
Discovery (6)
Litigation Tips (6)
Trial Irregularities and Structural Errors (6)
Motions to Vacate and Set Aside Judgments (5)
Notices of Entry (5)
Federal Appeals (5)
Legal Ethics and Professional Responsibility (5)
Summary Judgments (5)
Finding Compelled as a Matter of Law (Failure of Proof) Standard of Review (5)
Excessive Damages (5)
Standing (5)
Appealable Orders (4)
Right to Jury Trial (4)
Motions to Vacate (4)
Expert Opinions (4)
Tentative Rulings (4)
Appeals Treated as Writs (4)
Frivolous Motions (4)
Trust and Probate (4)
Demurrers (4)
Motions in Limine (4)
Disentitlement Doctrine (4)
Jury Waivers (3)
Prejudicial Error (3)
Landlord Tenant (3)
Frivolous Appeals (3)
Stays (3)
Law and Motion (3)
Recovery of Costs (3)
Pretrial Issues (3)
Amicus Briefs (3)
Summary Judgment (3)
Legal Tech (3)
Personal Jurisdiction (3)
Juror Peremptory Challenges (3)
Motions to Dismiss (3)
Jury Instructions (3)
Stare Decisis (2)
Contempt (2)
Judicial Admissions (2)
Waiver (2)
Class Actions (2)
Appeals Dismissed (2)
Medical Rights (2)
Pleadings (2)
Judicial Bias (2)
ADA and Unruh Accessibility Actions (2)
Record Designation (2)
Premature Appeals (2)
Harmless Error (2)
Podcasts (2)
Stipulated Reversals (2)
Alter Ego (2)
PAGA Actions (2)
Comments (2)
Legal Practice (2)
Remote Arguments (2)
Post Reversal Issues (2)
Finality and Final Orders (2)
Standards of Evidence (2)
Invited Error (2)
Untimeliness (2)
Constitutional Law (2)
Trial by Reference and Pro Tem Judges (2)
Attorney Client Privilege (2)
Civil Theft (2)
Forfeiture and Waiver (2)
Motions to Quash (1)
Preclusion (1)
Waived and Forfeiture (1)
Exhaustion of Remedies (1)
Notice of Appeal (1)
Punitive Damages (1)
Support Awards (1)
Free Exercise (1)
Attorney Fees - CCP 1021.5 (1)
DismissalsAppealability and Appealable Orders (1)
Record (1)
Tentative Opinions and Focus Letters (1)
Court Reporters (1)
Attorney Feese (1)
Clear and Convincing (1)
Covid (1)
Settled Statements (1)
Attorney Misconduct (1)
Judicial Estoppel (1)
New Arguments (1)
Administrative Law (1)
Clerks Service of File Stamped Judgment (1)
Family Court (1)
Third Parties and Nonparties (1)
Mistrials (1)
Typeface (1)
Bankruptcy (1)
Judicial Misconduct (1)
New Trial (1)
Premises Liability (1)
Writs of Mandamus (CCP 1085) (1)
Closing Argument (1)
Law of the Case (1)
Out-of-State Litigant (1)
Moot Appeals (1)
Post-Appellate Issues (1)
Split Decisions (1)
Typography (1)
Benefits Obtained Trespass Damages (1)
Employment Law (1)
Judicial Notice (1)
Referral Fees (1)
Inconsistent Verdicts (1)
Post Reversal (1)
Split of Authority (1)
U.S. Supreme Court (1)
Judicial Philosophy (1)
PAGA Attorney Fees (1)
Trade Restraints (1)
Designating the Record (1)
Incorrect Decisions (1)
Motions for Judgment on the Pleadings (1)
Ninth CircuitAbuse of Discretion (1)
Anecdotes (1)
Common Interest Doctrine (1)
Per Se Errors (1)
Treble Damages (1)
Dicta (1)
Inherent Authority (1)
PostJudgment Litigation (1)
Unsupported Arguments (1)
Evidentiary Presumptions (1)
Juror Misconduct (1)
Product Liability (1)
Consenting to Judgments (1)
Restraining Orders (1)
Trespass (1)
Civil Code 3334 (1)
Nonsuit (1)
Forfeiture (1)
Issue Selection on Appeal (1)
Precedent (1)
Nonsuits JNOVs and 631.8 Judgments (1)
Property Rights (1)
Summary Reversal (1)
Constitutional Litigation (1)
Local Rules (1)
Petitions for Rehearing (1)
Review as Writ Petition (1)
Landlore Tenant (0)
Appellate (0)
No categories Legal Writing (0)
Professional Ethics (0)
Petitionf ro Review (0)
Retainer Agreements (0)
crossmenuchevron-down