Legal News and Appellate Tips

Each week, TVA appellate attorney Tim Kowal reviews several recent decisions out of the appellate courts in California, and elsewhere, and reports about the ones that might help you get an edge in your cases and appeals.

If you would like to receive weekly updates of the articles posted here, click here to sign up for the newsletter.

Tag: Appeals Treated as Writs

Premature Appeal May Be Saved, But Get the Judgment Entered

Sometimes appeals are filed prematurely. Some classic examples are appeals taken from on order sustaining a demurrer (you need to wait for the dismissal), or from an order granting summary judgment (you need to wait for the judgment). The Court of Appeal may choose to “save” your premature appeal at treat it as taken from the subsequent judgment. But there is a condition, as the court recognized in Ortiz v. Related Mgmt. Co., L.P. (D2d1 Feb. 23, 2022, no. B307902) 2022 WL 537930 (nonpub. opn.).

That condition is: If you want to court to treat your appeal as taken from the subsequent judgment, make sure there is a subsequent judgment.

While the court was rather fussy about the requirement here, in the post I mention some of the creative ways that other courts — if sufficiently motivated to reach the merits — will save an appeal. My favorite: the appellate court can order the trial judge to enter a nunc pro tunc judgment, and then the appeal can proceed as though taken from that future judgment. (Someone, at last, found a way to apply the deep time-travel lessons of Bill and Ted’s Excellent Adventure!)

Question for #AppellateLinkedIn: Do appellate courts in other states get this creative?

Read More
Court Suggests, Surprisingly, That Summary Adjudication Order Could Be Appealable As Collateral Order (But Just Not in This Case)

Devastating trial court orders should be appealable. That is a natural assumption. And that it why it can be disconcerting to learn about appeals dismissed on grounds of nonappealability. (That is why I write about them.)

But actually, the opposite may be true: When more orders are made independently appealable, it means there is more risk that, by the time you get a final judgment, large chunks of your case will now be beyond appellate review. Failing to get review right away is far less devastating than getting no review at all.

The Fourth District Court of Appeal offers a reminder of this in State of California v. Southern California Edison Co. (D4d2 Sep. 30, 2021) 2021 WL 4471627 no. E074138 (nonpub. opn.). The court held an order granting summary adjudication on a declaratory relief claim was not appealable as a collateral order because it did not order the immediate performance of an act or payment of money. The court distinguished a similar case where declaratory relief, also summarily adjudicated, was found to be appealable. In that other case, the trial court also entered an enforcement order. The Edison court noted that, had the underlying MSA been found appealable, then it would have been unreviewable by the time the enforcement order was entered — two years later.

The lesson is that a too-easy rule of appealability could actually make it harder to get review, not easier, because parties would have to file several appeals along the way to a judgment, or else forfeit them as untimely.

Get a weekly digest of these articles delivered to your inbox by subscribing here: https://lnkd.in/g23bc4Y.

Read More
A Writ Petition Summarily Denied May Be Raised Again Later

Getting writ review in the Court of Appeal is rare – even when writ review is the only appropriate means of review. In a recent opinion in LSG Las Tunas, LP v. A & R Corporation, Inc. (D2d2 Jul. 29, 2021) no. B307534 (nonpub. opn.), the appellant filed a writ petition along with its appeal, but the court summarily denied the writ petition. Later, the court realized writ review was appropriate, and so treated the appeal as a writ.

The procedural curiosity probably came to nothing – the appeal-turned-writ was unsuccessful anyway – but it underscores how difficult it can be to get a writ petition off on the right foot.

The case prompts one to ask: How many other writ petitions that are legitimately worthy of writ review are getting waste-binned during the court's rushed initial review?

Get a weekly digest of these articles delivered to your inbox by subscribing here: https://lnkd.in/g23bc4Y.

Read More
Charles Manson's Grandson Not Required to Submit to DNA Testing, Court of Appeal Holds

The Second District Court of Appeal has the latest update in the fight over Charles Manson's estate. After Manson died in 2017, the probate court ordered Freeman was the sole surviving adult next of kin, and authorized to determine the disposition of Manson's remains. Manson penpal and "murderabilia" collector Channels disputed Freeman's kinship, and moved for genetic testing under Probate Code section 6453.

But there is no authority to require genetic testing under section 6453. So held (and without much trouble, really) the Second District in Freeman v. Channels (D2d2 Apr. 13, 2021) no. B303594 (not published).

Before reaching the question, however, the court found a jurisdictional defect. The court concluded the order appealed was not an appealable order. But the court exercised its discretion to treat the appeal as a writ petition because the improper genetic test "will involve an invasion of Freeman's privacy that cannot be undone," leaving Freeman with "no adequate remedy at law."

So Freeman will get to handle the disposition of Manson's remains. He is legally (perhaps strictly so) the prevailing party.

Read More

Tags

Podcast (101)
Videos (90)
Appealability and Appealable Orders (34)
Legal Writing (26)
Abuse of Discretion (24)
Mischief (22)
Unpublished Opinions (21)
Anti-SLAPP (21)
Splits of Authority (20)
Notices of Appeal (19)
Stays on Appeal (19)
California Supreme Court (19)
Statements of Decision (18)
Waiver and Forfeiture (18)
Record on Appeal (17)
Attorney Fees (16)
Arbitration (16)
Judgment Enforcement (15)
Oral Argument (14)
Dismissals (14)
Sanctions (13)
Dissents (13)
Briefing (12)
Evidentiary Objections (12)
Exclusion of Evidence (12)
Trial Strategy (12)
Preliminary Injunctions (11)
Timeliness (11)
Family Law (11)
Timely and Untimely Appeals (11)
New Trial Motions (11)
Mootness (11)
Collateral Orders (11)
Jurisdiction (11)
Appellate Sanctions (11)
CCP 998 Offers (11)
Civility (10)
Experts (10)
Federal Courts (10)
Motions for Reconsideration (10)
Dismissed Appeals (9)
Writ Petitions (9)
Implied Findings (9)
Posttrial Motions (9)
Summary Judgments and Summary Adjudications (9)
Settlements (8)
Appealability (8)
Trial Procedure (8)
Disqualification (7)
Default Judgments (7)
Ninth Circuit (7)
Probate Appeals (7)
Respondent Arguments (7)
Stipulated Judgments (6)
Admission of Improper Evidence (6)
Appellate Bonds (6)
Ethical Duty of Candor (6)
Substantial Evidence (6)
Appellate Practice (6)
Discovery (6)
Standards of Review (6)
Mediation (6)
Motions to Vacate and Set Aside Judgments (5)
Federal Appeals (5)
Legal Ethics and Professional Responsibility (5)
Depublished Opinions (5)
Summary Judgments (5)
Finding Compelled as a Matter of Law (Failure of Proof) Standard of Review (5)
Trial Irregularities and Structural Errors (5)
Standing (5)
Petitions for Review (5)
Motions to Vacate (4)
Expert Opinions (4)
Trust and Probate (4)
Notices of Entry (4)
Frivolous Motions (4)
Appeals Treated as Writs (4)
Motions in Limine (4)
Excessive Damages (4)
Litigation Tips (4)
Disentitlement Doctrine (4)
Prejudicial Error (3)
Landlord Tenant (3)
Tentative Rulings (3)
Appealable Orders (3)
Frivolous Appeals (3)
Stays (3)
Recovery of Costs (3)
Demurrers (3)
Pretrial Procedure (3)
Appellate Briefing (3)
Summary Judgment (3)
Amicus Briefs (3)
Legal Tech (3)
Personal Jurisdiction (3)
Juror Peremptory Challenges (3)
Motions to Dismiss (3)
Jury Instructions (3)
Jury Waivers (3)
Right to Jury Trial (3)
Judicial Admissions (2)
Contempt (2)
Medical Rights (2)
Pleadings (2)
Judicial Bias (2)
Class Actions (2)
Record Designation (2)
Appeals Dismissed (2)
Premature Appeals (2)
ADA and Unruh Accessibility Actions (2)
Law and Motion (2)
Harmless Error (2)
Podcasts (2)
Pretrial Issues (2)
Stipulated Reversals (2)
PAGA Actions (2)
Alter Ego (2)
Legal Practice (2)
Remote Arguments (2)
Post Reversal Issues (2)
Comments (2)
Finality and Final Orders (2)
Standards of Evidence (2)
Untimeliness (2)
Trial by Reference and Pro Tem Judges (2)
Invited Error (2)
Constitutional Law (2)
Forfeiture and Waiver (2)
Attorney Client Privilege (2)
Waiver (2)
DismissalsAppealability and Appealable Orders (1)
Record (1)
Attorney Fees - CCP 1021.5 (1)
Third Parties and Nonparties (1)
Covid (1)
Settled Statements (1)
Typeface (1)
Attorney Feese (1)
Judicial Estoppel (1)
New Arguments (1)
Writs of Mandamus (CCP 1085) (1)
Clear and Convincing (1)
Family Court (1)
Mistrials (1)
Typography (1)
Attorney Misconduct (1)
Judicial Misconduct (1)
New Trial (1)
Premises Liability (1)
Administrative Law (1)
Clerks Service of File Stamped Judgment (1)
Law of the Case (1)
Out-of-State Litigant (1)
Moot Appeals (1)
Post-Appellate Issues (1)
Split Decisions (1)
U.S. Supreme Court (1)
Bankruptcy (1)
Employment Law (1)
Judicial Notice (1)
Closing Argument (1)
Referral Fees (1)
Trade Restraints (1)
Inconsistent Verdicts (1)
Post Reversal (1)
Benefits Obtained Trespass Damages (1)
Judicial Philosophy (1)
PAGA Attorney Fees (1)
Treble Damages (1)
Designating the Record (1)
Incorrect Decisions (1)
Motions for Judgment on the Pleadings (1)
Unsupported Arguments (1)
Ninth CircuitAbuse of Discretion (1)
Per Se Errors (1)
Trespass (1)
Dicta (1)
Inherent Authority (1)
PostJudgment Litigation (1)
Evidentiary Presumptions (1)
Juror Misconduct (1)
Product Liability (1)
Anecdotes (1)
Common Interest Doctrine (1)
Restraining Orders (1)
Nonsuit (1)
Consenting to Judgments (1)
Forfeiture (1)
Issue Selection on Appeal (1)
Precedent (1)
Waived and Forfeiture (1)
Civil Code 3334 (1)
Nonsuits JNOVs and 631.8 Judgments (1)
Property Rights (1)
Summary Reversal (1)
Local Rules (1)
Petitions for Rehearing (1)
Review as Writ Petition (1)
Motions to Quash (1)
Preclusion (1)
Stare Decisis (1)
Civil Theft (1)
Exhaustion of Remedies (1)
Punitive Damages (1)
Support Awards (1)
Constitutional Litigation (1)
Free Exercise (1)
Landlore Tenant (0)
Appellate (0)
Split of Authority (0)
No categories Legal Writing (0)
Professional Ethics (0)
Petitionf ro Review (0)
Retainer Agreements (0)
Notice of Appeal (0)
crossmenuchevron-down